Our Strange Catholic Moment.

The article focuses on the current state of American Catholicism, highlighting its significant numerical decline in areas such as school enrollment, weddings, and baptisms since 2000. Despite this decline, Catholic ideas and terminology have gained prominence in public and political debates, exempli...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:First Things: A Monthly Journal of Religion & Public Life no. 364; pp. 14 - 16
Main Author: Schmitz, Matthew
Format: Article
Published: Institute on Religion & Public Life Jun/Jul2026
Subjects:
Online Access:View this record in EBSCOhost
Description
Summary:The article focuses on the current state of American Catholicism, highlighting its significant numerical decline in areas such as school enrollment, weddings, and baptisms since 2000. Despite this decline, Catholic ideas and terminology have gained prominence in public and political debates, exemplified by discussions involving concepts like "ordo amoris" (a Catholic theological term for the hierarchy of loves) and just war theory during the second Trump administration. This period is described as one of "Catholic ferment," where institutional shrinkage coexists with increased cultural and intellectual influence, partly due to a rise in adult conversions and the Church’s broad sociological reach across political and demographic lines. The article also notes that Catholicism’s distinct identity and universal appeal may contribute to its unexpected centrality in American public life, even as overall membership declines.