"Vidyā" and "Avidyā": Simultaneous and Coterminous?—a Holographic Model to Illuminate the Advaita Debate.

The Advaita Vedānta notion of ātman/Brahman presents a serious philosophical challenge to this school—namely, it demands that they explain how all (reality) can be undivided, unchanging, and pure consciousness, yet appear to be everything but nondual, unchanging, and pure consciousness. The Advaita...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:Philosophy East & West: A Quarterly of Comparative Philosophy Vol. 57; no. 2; pp. 178 - 204
Main Author: Kaplan, Stephen
Format: Article
Published: University of Hawai'i Apr2007
Subjects:
Online Access:View this record in EBSCOhost
Description
Summary:The Advaita Vedānta notion of ātman/Brahman presents a serious philosophical challenge to this school—namely, it demands that they explain how all (reality) can be undivided, unchanging, and pure consciousness, yet appear to be everything but nondual, unchanging, and pure consciousness. The Advaita answer is "avidyā, aj&ntildeāna" (ignorance). This answer tells us that Brahman does not really change; it is only ignorance that makes it appear to change. This answer has engendered as many questions as it has resolved, and it is possible that they can be boiled down to the following: how can "vidyā" and "avidyā" be simultaneous and coterminous? After reviewing the Advaita responses to the debates regarding "avidyā," which arose within Advaita and between Advaitins and their opponents, a traditional Advaita path will be followed by offering an analogy to illuminate this quandary. The strength of this contemporary analogy, based on holography, lies in its ability to illuminate the nature of Brahman as being without parts, without duality, without change; yet holography presents us with images that appear to change and be with parts.