Overextending Partial Structures: Idealization and Abstraction.

The partial structures program of da Costa, French and others offers a unified framework within which to handle a wide range of issues central to contemporary philosophy of science. I argue that the program is inadequately equipped to account for simple cases where idealizations are used to construc...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:Philosophy of Science Vol. 72; no. 5; pp. 1248 - 1260
Main Author: Pincock, Christopher
Format: Article
Published: Cambridge University Press Dec2005
Subjects:
Online Access:View this record in EBSCOhost
Description
Summary:The partial structures program of da Costa, French and others offers a unified framework within which to handle a wide range of issues central to contemporary philosophy of science. I argue that the program is inadequately equipped to account for simple cases where idealizations are used to construct abstract, mathematical models of physical systems. These problems show that da Costa and French have not overcome the objections raised by Cartwright and Suárez using model-theoretic techniques in the philosophy of science. However, my concerns arise independently of the more controversial assumptions that Cartwright and Suárez have employed.