GATEKEEPING IN FIELD PERFORMANCE: IS GRADE INFLATION A GIVEN?

This field note presents the results of a pilot study that explored the use of a new non-numerically rated field performance tool, a vignette matching measure for MSW students. Evaluation of performance in the field has proved to be a difficult task because few if any measures, including competency-...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:Journal of Social Work Education Vol. 47; no. 2; pp. 367 - 378
Main Author: Sowbel, Lynda R.
Format: Article
Published: Taylor & Francis Ltd Spring/Summer2011
Subjects:
Online Access:View this record in EBSCOhost
Description
Summary:This field note presents the results of a pilot study that explored the use of a new non-numerically rated field performance tool, a vignette matching measure for MSW students. Evaluation of performance in the field has proved to be a difficult task because few if any measures, including competency-based measures, have known levels of reliability and validity. Field instructors rated a sample of 154 students. Over half of the students were rated as exceptional, which may support the long-standing notion that performance ratings are inflated. Implications for social work education and research are discussed.